Black Transmission Fluid Jamestown NY

The topic of this article is issues with car transmissions. The car owner in this article has found black transmission fluid and wants to know what to do about it. See what the Honest Mechanic says and see what you should do if you find yourself in the same situation in Jamestown.

Local Companies

Goodyear Tire & AAA Auto Service Center
(716) 763-1844
333 E Fairmount Ave
Lakewood, NY
Spony's Garage
1436 Foote Avenue EXT
Jamestown, NY
Spony's Auto & Truck Repair
3970 N Main Street EXT
Jamestown, NY
Henry J Dahl Jr
497 Follett Run Rd
Warren, PA
Safelite Auto Glass
(888) 820-2558
1514 Washington St
Jamestown, NY
Electric Motor Specialties
(716) 487-1458
490 Crescent Street%2C %23 496
Jamestown, NY
Carlson's VW Service
45 N Chicago Ave
Jamestown, NY
Kendall Oil & Lube Mainte
1755 Foote Avenue EXT
Jamestown, NY
Monro Muffler Brake & Services
80 Hatch Run Rd
Warren, PA
Sponys Auto & Truck Repair
Jamestown, NY

Provided by:

Reader Question

Hi Austin,

A couple of times, I had a bit of a delay engaging into reverse in my 1990 Mercedes 300e with 200K miles. Automatic transmission fluild is black. Otherwise car runs great. Gave
this car to my daughter to go around town.

Can you tell me.

Is it safe?

Can I do damage to the car tranny by waiting to do a tranny job.

Will a tranny service help?

How long before the tranny dies/

Thanks much. I'm not sure if I should spend 2500 on a tranny job or if I can keep it around for a couple of years till my daugher goes to college.

thanks again


Hi there Lew,

If you are experiencing a transmission problem, like a slip, It is normally advisable to NOT change the transmission fluid unless you are prepared to overhaul the transmission. I have serviced the fluid and filter on 2 vehicles that drove into my shop but did not drive out.

The transmission fluid was burnt smelling and very dirty and the vehicles had high mileage on them. The dirty gritty fluid was the only thing the transmission had to produce the friction needed to move the vehicle.

With that being said, do you feel comfortable with your daughter driving a vehicle that possibly will require a transmission overhaul away from home where you can’t look at the mechanic eye to eye yourself? Personally, a soon to be 17 year old vehicle with the signs of an upcoming EXPENSIVE transmission overhaul...I would sell in a heart beat. Take the money from the sale and use it to buy her a new 2006 Kia Rio, and super great kids car. Kia might even have 0% interest financing.

To read the full article, visit
Related Articles
- Burned Up Transmission Jamestown NY
A car owner asks the Honest Mechanic about some transmission-related issues. The car owner wonders if his transmission is burned up. Find out what the Honest Mechanic has to say and get some useful information in case you ever find yourself facing similar problems with your car.
- Ferrari 612 Scaglietti Jamestown NY
- Automatic Transmission Slipping Jamestown NY
- Automatic Transmission Slow to Reverse Jamestown NY
- Automatic Transmission Flush Jamestown NY
- Automatic Transmission Problem Jamestown NY
- Ford Mustang GT Jamestown NY
- Chevrolet Corvette Convertible Jamestown NY
- Automatic Transmission Jerks Jamestown NY